📉 SEO Is Losing Ground — Here’s How To Prove It Still Works (In the AI Era)

Hey, Shane here

If you feel like SEO is getting harder, you’re not imagining it.

AI is rewriting how search works and measuring content value. Rankings matter less. Relevance matters more.

That’s a scary shift. Especially if your boss, client, or investor is still hung up on keyword reports or #1 Google spots.

So let’s talk about how you can prove the real value of SEO in an AI-driven world and what metrics move the needle today.

🚨 SEO Isn’t Dead. But It Has Changed.

The game used to be simple:

• Rank for high-volume keywords
  

• Optimize technical SEO
  

• Build backlinks
  

• Watch traffic climb
  

Now, Google’s Search Generative Experience (SGE) and tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Claude are changing everything.

Search engines are no longer just search engines; they’re answer engines. AI is summarizing content and giving users what they want — without having to click through.

That means your content could be ranking and still never get seen.

If you don’t adapt, your visibility will fade fast.

🧠 How To Prove SEO Is Still Worth It (Even Without Rankings)

Whether you're pitching a boss, a client, or just trying to justify your own strategy — here are 5 high-impact ways to show that SEO is still delivering results in 2025.

1. Track AI Visibility, Not Just Rankings

Tools like ZipTie.dev and Semrush now help you track whether your content shows up in AI Overviews.

👉 Example: You may be ranking #2 in Google, but if you're not mentioned in the AI-generated answer at the top, you will not gain traffic.

So, track:

• Which keywords trigger AI Overviews
  

• Whether your content is cited or referenced
  

• The difference in traffic before and after AI rollouts
  

This lets you map real visibility in AI experiences, not just SERP rankings.

2. Monitor AI Mentions Across Platforms

Being mentioned by AI is the new PR.

Want to know if ChatGPT recommends your brand for “best eCommerce agency” or “SEO audit experts”?

Use tools like Brand24, Ahrefs Brand Radar, or Mention to track brand mentions in AI summaries.

Build authority where AI gets its data:

• Forums like Reddit and Quora
  

• YouTube videos and podcasts
  

• Authoritative blogs and media
  

• Structured schema (like FAQ or How-To)
  

You’re not just optimizing for Google anymore. You’re optimizing for everywhere AI pulls from.

3. Track AI Citations Like a Backlink Profile

Ahrefs just launched AI Citation tracking, which shows when your domain gets cited by:

• ChatGPT
  

• Google AI Overviews
  

• Perplexity
  

• Claude and more…

This is your AI “off-page SEO” score.

If your content is cited frequently, it means AI trusts you. That’s a signal of authority and expertise — especially crucial for YMYL or EEAT-related industries.

Use this data in client or stakeholder reports to show you’re winning trust in the new algorithm.

4. Watch Branded Search Trends

Here’s a secret: AI search rewards strong brands.

As search engines focus more on entities (not just keywords), branded searches matter more.

Track:

• How often people search your brand
  

• If AI platforms suggest your company as a source
  

• Whether reviews, podcasts, and roundups mention you
  

👉 Bonus tip: Use schema and structured data to help AI understand your entity better.
Organization, Author, FAQPage, and Product schemas are your best friends.

5. Use GA4 + GSC To Track AI Traffic Patterns

Google is (finally) giving us some AI-specific insights in GSC.

Inside Search Console, you can now track:

• Clicks and impressions from AI Mode
  

• Positions in AI blocks
  

• Follow-up question visibility
  

In GA4, set up custom reports that track AI traffic patterns using regex filters:

ini

CopyEdit

utm_source=chatgpt  

utm_medium=ai  

utm_source=perplexity  

AI might only represent 0.5% of your traffic…

However, brands are reporting 23X higher conversion rates from those users.

If that’s not ROI, what is?

💡 Bottom Line: It’s Time To Rethink SEO Reporting

Old SEO reports won’t cut it anymore.

If you’re still showing keyword movements and traffic alone, you’re missing the real story.

Today, you need to show:

• AI visibility
  

• AI trust (citations + mentions)
  

• Entity recognition
  

• Conversion impact (even if traffic is lower)

That’s the narrative stakeholders care about.

💼 Need Help Proving SEO Value?

If you’re feeling overwhelmed trying to show results in this new landscape, let’s talk.

At Shane Barker Consulting, we help brands:

✅ Target keywords your audience searches for

✅ Build lasting authority with smart content

✅ Attract high-intent visitors who stick around

✅ Stay ahead of every algorithm update

✅ Track real SEO growth with actual, proven results

You don’t have to do it alone. And you definitely don’t want to fall behind.

👉 Book a strategy session now — let’s make your SEO future-proof.

You’ve got this,
Shane

Looking for more in-depth strategies and exclusive content?

Check out my Gumroad page for courses, guides, and tools that can help take your digital marketing to the next level. Whether you're looking to master SEO, influencer marketing, or content strategies, I've got resources to get you there. Plus, you'll find some free content to help you get started right away!

Visit my Gumroad page and explore everything I have to offer!

1. Found the insights helpful? Forward this email to help fellow business owners or marketers.

2. Spread the word. Encourage your friends or followers to sign up.

3.  Have us test and review your marketing or business tool on ShaneBarker.com. We can write a product review, comparison, or industry listicle for you.

If you have any specific questions or topics you'd like us to cover in future newsletters, please feel free to reach out. We'd love to hear from you!

To your content marketing success,
Shane Barker