🤖 New Study: AI Prefers AI-Written Content (Here’s What It Means for You)

A new peer-reviewed study just revealed something that could change the way we all approach content.

Large language models — the same systems driving AI search, product recommendations, and even content discovery — prefer AI-written text over human-written content.

If that made you pause, you’re not alone.

What the Study Found

Researchers compared human-written and AI-written versions of the identical text across three categories:

• Marketplace product descriptions
  

• Scientific paper abstracts
  

• Movie summaries

They then asked popular models such as GPT-3.5, GPT-4, Llama-3, and Mixtral to choose between them in pairwise tests.

The results? Eye-opening:

• Products: LLMs chose AI-written copy 89% of the time (vs. 36% for humans).
  

• Paper abstracts: 78% preference for AI vs. 61% for humans.
  

• Movie summaries: 70% vs. 58%.
  

The pattern was clear: when asked to pick, AI systems consistently preferred text written by other AIs.

Why This Matters for You

This isn’t just an academic curiosity.

Think about it: if AI is now powering search results, marketplace rankings, and recommendation engines, then the systems deciding what gets seen may already be biased toward AI-generated content.

That new data means human-only content could be at a disadvantage — even if it’s better written, more insightful, or more authentic.

The researchers even warned of a potential “gate tax” where businesses may feel compelled to use AI tools to avoid being buried by AI selectors.

The Hidden Risk

Here’s where things get tricky.

If every brand starts using AI just to stay visible, we could see:
✅ A flood of generic, optimized-but-soulless copy
✅ Consumers tuning out because everything sounds the same
✅ Human creativity undervalued in the race for algorithmic approval

That’s not the game you want to play.

Instead, strategic brands will learn how to blend AI efficiency with human creativity — giving them the best of both worlds.

What You Can Do Now

So how do you adapt? How do you make sure your content stays visible to AI systems and resonates with human readers?

Here are five steps I recommend:

✅ Experiment with AI assistance, not replacement.
Use AI tools to generate drafts, product copy, or variations. But always refine with human editing to add clarity, voice, and credibility.

✅ Optimize for “AI readability.”
LLMs seem to favor structured, clear, and concise content. Think short paragraphs, well-organized sections, and straightforward wording.

✅ Validate with humans.
AI preference doesn’t guarantee conversions. Test your copy with real customers. If it doesn’t resonate with people, it doesn’t matter how AI scores it.

✅ Track visibility metrics.
Watch how your content performs on marketplaces, search, and social. If AI-written or AI-assisted content gets more impressions, clicks, or rankings, note the pattern.

✅ Keep the human edge.
Infuse stories, case studies, and insights AI can’t replicate. This is where your brand builds trust and emotional connection.

My Take

Here’s the bottom line:

We’re heading into a world where AI isn’t just creating content — it’s also deciding which content wins.

That creates both risk and opportunity.

The risk: ignoring this shift and sticking with a “humans only” approach could make your brand less visible in AI-driven platforms.

The opportunity: if you use AI strategically — to pass through algorithmic gates while keeping the human voice intact — you’ll have a massive edge.

This is why I always recommend experimenting now, while the landscape is still forming. The brands that adapt early will own visibility tomorrow.

Looking Ahead

As AI continues to shape search, commerce, and discovery, expect to see more studies like this.

For you, the key is balance:

• Let AI help you get through the gates.
  

• Let humans keep your brand authentic and trusted.

That’s how you’ll thrive in the next era of digital marketing.

I’ll leave you with this thought:

AI may prefer AI-written content. But humans still buy from humans.

The brands that remember both truths — and master the mix — will be the ones who win.

Talk soon,
Shane

Looking for more in-depth strategies and exclusive content?

Check out my Gumroad page for courses, guides, and tools that can help take your digital marketing to the next level. Whether you're looking to master SEO, influencer marketing, or content strategies, I've got resources to get you there. Plus, you'll find some free content to help you get started right away!

Visit my Gumroad page and explore everything I have to offer!

1. Found the insights helpful? Forward this email to help fellow business owners or marketers.

2. Spread the word. Encourage your friends or followers to sign up.

3.  Have us test and review your marketing or business tool on ShaneBarker.com. We can write a product review, comparison, or industry listicle for you.

If you have any specific questions or topics you'd like us to cover in future newsletters, please feel free to reach out. We'd love to hear from you!

To your content marketing success,
Shane Barker